Here’s the deal:
Underwear is something that a lot of people take for granted. It’s hard to explain how much of a real and tangible difference that having a nice pair of underwear can make if you’ve never bothered to have that experience.
When you shell out, what you can expect in return is comfort, care, and support in a way that is unparalleled.
Now, where to begin?
One of the best makers of underwear is Mack Weldon. Mack Weldon is an established seller of all sorts of staples, from socks to undies to tops.
Their underwear line is second to none, with a variety of fabrics offered and different fits available. While there is a lot of very nice underwear by this brand, our number one pick is the cream of the crop.
So enjoy our best Mack Weldon underwear review, as we guide you through our list of the best underwear they have to offer.
#1 Most Luxe Brief
Silver Boxer Brief
- Design of the more traditional boxer brief, but with super high-quality anti-odor Silver cotton
- Extremely soft with excellent moisture control
- The cotton used is superbly durable and will take a lot of use and abuse
- No-roll waistband and cool mesh zones
Pros
Extreme comfort and control make these expensive boxer briefs worth every penny. World-class Supima® cotton combined with antimicrobial Silver XT2 is ideal for long days.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
10/10
The Silver cotton fabric is extremely soft and porous, with tons of airflow and extremely great moisture control. Everybody wears underwear, but not many pairs of underwear are as enjoyable as these bad boys. Super comfortable and feel luxurious under your clothes.
Uses
10/10
With the advanced moisture control and extreme comfort, these are great both for activity as well as wearing them around the office. They pair well with long days in suits because they’re unobtrusive and super breathable.
Value
9.5/10
These are $34 a pop. That’s a lot of dough to drop on underwear, especially when a week means needing several pairs, but if you want to splurge and just have a super nice pair to treat yourself for long days, these are a great option.
Overall Editor Score
9.8/10
#2 Best Light-As-Air Trunk
AIRKNITx Trunk
- Another trunk, this time in different, super light material
- A light-fitting knit is remarkably comfortable as well as adaptable
- Constant airflow wicks away sweat and prevents chafing
Pros
Extremely airy material gives you the circulation you need when doing strenuous stuff.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
10/10
Similar to other trunks by Mack Weldon, but this one uses AIRKNITx microfiber fabric instead. As a result, it’s a lot more breathable. 50% Polyamide / 33% Polyester / 17% Elastane.
Uses
9.9/10
These are great sporting underwear. They’d also be nice for hiking, cycling, and any other time where you’re moving your legs a lot and really need the breathability. A great option for athletes.
Value
9.6/10
Only $26 for some of the most breathable underwear you can find – we’ll take that deal any day!
Overall Editor Score
9.8/10
#3 Best Long Underwear
Tech Cashmere Long Underwear
- These are the only long johns that Mack Weldon has on offer… and the only long johns that Mack Weldon needs to offer
- Fantastic whole-leg protection in that way that only long johns can provide
- Stay-put ankle cuffs
- Made from cashmere and incredibly warm and delicate
Pros
The long and short of it is that these keep you warm when you need it most with natural thermoregulation. So comfy you won’t want to change. Ever.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
10/10
These are made from silver cashmere and hug the entire leg. The result is an extremely comfortable set of long johns that keeps you protected and warm. 47% Modal / 38% Merino Wool / 10% Cashmere / 5% Spandex.
Uses
9.5/10
The main time that you’re going to wear these is going to be in the winter months. In places with a cold or even harsh winter, long johns can make up for the fact that coats keep your torso warm but not your legs. Just the single added layer can do a lot for your insulation and warmth.
Value
9.7/10
When all is said and done, these are super pricey, but they’re worth every penny. Unparalleled comfort and warmth for the money.
Overall Editor Score
9.7/10
#4 Best Every Day Underwear
18-Hour Jersey Boxer Brief
- The classic boxer brief design
- Built to last all day with no trouble
- A ton of different colors and design choices
- No-roll waistline
Pros
With cool mesh zones and a no-roll waistline, these can be worn all day, every day, and are perfect for any situation.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
9.7/10
A lot of people describe boxer briefs as having the ideal middle ground fit between boxers, which are too loose, and briefs, which can hug too much and be too tight. We think every kind of underwear has a time and place. But these do have a really nice and comfortable fit, and the 18-Hour cotton/modal/spandex blend is great for wicking sweat and moisture and keeping you dry. 47.5% Cotton / 47.5% Modal / 5% Spandex.
Uses
9.9/10
These are ideal everyday underwear that will port well between activities. Whether lounging, sporting, or just running errands, this jack-of-all-trades underwear will cover it all.
Value
9.4/10
One pair is $24, which is average for high-quality underwear. Not the greatest value, but not half bad either.
Overall Editor Score
9.7/10
#5 Best Classic Trunk
18-Hour Jersey Trunk
- Jersey trunk style for those who want something that fits a bit closer
- Same material as boxer briefs
- Extremely soft; just what you’re expecting and wanting most
Pros
A comfortably close fit and airy fabric make this trunk a great option for errands and the everyday.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
9.7/10
These have the same material as the 18-Hour boxer briefs, but offer a closer trunk fit. 47.5% Cotton / 47.5% Modal / 5% Spandex and available in lots of colors and styles.
Uses
9.6/10
Ideal for when you think you may end up chafing with regular boxers.
Value
9.6/10
At only $22, these are a pretty fantastic deal considering how comfortable and durable they are.
Overall Editor Score
9.6/10
#6 Most Comfy Boxer
18-Hour Knit Boxer
- Similar to the woven boxer but with the 18-Hour material
- Breathable with excellent moisture wicking
- Extremely free and comfortable, making it ideal for days spent lounging around the house
Pros
These give you the freedom of a boxer with the versatility of breathable fabric.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
9.6/10
Reminiscent of the woven boxer, but more breathable and stretchy. As a plus, you also get all the general 18-Hour fabric options you get with the boxer briefs and trunk.
Uses
9.8/10
These are incredible for lounging around. They’re super comfortable, airy, and great for sleeping or relaxing. They’re great in most other situations, too, but lounging is where they really shine!
Value
9.1/10
$28 for breathable boxers fit for everyday wear. If you prefer boxers over briefs or trunks, these aren’t a bad deal.
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
#7 Best Two-Way Stretch
Woven Boxer
- A classy and classic boxer
- Two-way stretch keeps boxers from riding up and allows a tailored fit
- Button fly is a nice touch that not all boxers have
Pros
Mack Weldon’s take on the classic boxer is luxurious, comfortable, and well-fitting.
Product Ratings
Material & Fit
9.4/10
Primarily cotton, these boxers fit loose and feel similar to a lot of other cotton clothing. They’re not meant for high-stress activity, so avoid wearing them in situations where you’re going to be really active. 98% Cotton / 2% Spandex.
Uses
9.6/10
Really, these are best worn with casual wear on errand days. Things like slacks or joggers will pair well with these boxers and allow you to enjoy their roominess while still being low-intensity enough that it doesn’t come back to bite you by way of a split seam.
Value
9.4/10
$28 for high-quality, sophisticated boxers. That’s fairly average, and certainly not a bad investment.
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
Men’s Underwear Tips
Underwear is an investment, and a sound one. That’s because good underwear is also a treat. You may not think about it much right now, but just buy one pair and you’ll see the immense change that the added support and comfort brings. Best of all, good underwear can last years, so it’s a very irregular purchase when you actually buy quality. Do yourself a favor and buy a pair of Mack Weldons.
