10 Best Hair Clays for Men

9.4/10

 idering this is especially for guys with fine and thinning hair, you shouldn’t expect it to be super strong. That said, it’s definitely more than a medium, and you still get plenty of flexibility with it. If you are working with truly fine hair, then expect a strong hold, but not a weighted one.

when used by guys with fine and thinning hair, you’ll get a full 18 hours hold out of it. For the guys with denser or thicker hair, you shouldn’t expect more than 12-14, which is still more than enough for most guys.

Texture

9.4/10

It’s a light, non-gritty clay-like texture.

Application

9.3/10

The formula makes it really easy to apply a dime-sized amount to damp or dry hair. You won’t get any clumps, even if you don’t work it too hard in your hands beforehand. Nice, right?

Washing ease

9.4/10

Easy peasy, you shouldn’t expect it to take any effort at all.

Scent

9.5/10

The smell is a little difficult to put your finger on, the manufacturers say it smells like a “freshly bathed TIGER.” What we can say is that it mostly smells clean and manly – and darn good at that.

Key ingredients

9.1/10

The primary clay in here is bentonite. There’s also mineral oil, beeswax, and lanolin. Sadly, you will find a little alcohol in here, but it is paraben-free.

Overall Editor Score

9.4/10

If your hair is naturally fine or you’re beginning to experience thinning, you need to take a serious look at this product. Like right now. It’s amazing.

For a start, it will definitely make your hair look, well, fatter. You’ll be able to work with it in ways you didn’t expect, as you can achieve some piecing, without exposing your scalp in that horrifying way you may be experiencing with other products.

It’s a medium to strong, all day hold and it smells exactly like you want your men’s hair products to smell. Basically, it’s all things that are good, with a matte finish that doesn’t frighten you or anyone else.

While it is on the pricier side, it’s absolutely the right clay for this hair type, and therefore, usually worth it. More than that, it goes in easily and comes out in a snap.

9.6/10

Expect a strong hold. They’re not messing about here. It could be a little too much for fine hair, but most other men are going to fall head over heels for this clay.

It’ll hold all day. No really, you shouldn’t worry that your hair is going to flop when you make a last minute decision to go out dancing (after the drinks or dinner you also didn’t think you’d say yes to).

Texture

8.7/10

It’s a thick whitish-grayish putty. And, we do mean thick, but it is pliable.

Application

9.1/10

You will definitely need to work this clay in your hands before you place it in your hair. If you try to shortcut here, you will be disappointed in the results. Once you’ve worked it in your hands, however, it’s super easy to apply.

Washing ease

8.8/10

It’s on the easy side, but you can’t expect to get it out of your hair without shampoo. It’s a little too strong for just water.

Scent

9.2/10

Most users won’t even notice the smell. There, kind of, isn’t one. But, it smells like a mix of wax and clay; you know, sort of like you’d imagine this product to smell like.

Key ingredients

9.2/10

It’s a mix of beeswax, as well as bentonite and kaolin clays. You will find nourishing castor oil inside, but you won’t find any parabens. Basically, it’s an amazing formulation (though not an all-natural one).

Overall Editor Score

9.1/10

There is almost no reason not to give this product full marks; it’s a rather amazing hair clay. Yes, it does have some beeswax in the mix, but there are also plenty of ingredients that you would find in any real hair clay.

So, it’s authentic, which is always a good start…but it gets even better. The hold is strong to super strong. We kind of love that, because you actually want a clay with some hold otherwise it just thickens your hair. After all, clays – this one included – have a matte finish. It more or less should look like you have nothing in your hair, and this one is exemplary.

The smell, if you notice it at all, is pleasant and earthy (like wax and clay should be). But, most people don’t even notice it. That’s probably a great thing for most guys as you want something that’s not going to interfere with your other products.

It washes out easily, though you will need shampoo to get this clay out of your hair (it does an amazing job of really clinging to the hair to make it appear thicker). And, for the most part, it also goes on smoothly, though you will need to work with it in your hands first.

If they could bring the price down on this, it would be 100% perfect. But,  idering it has everything else in exactly the right place, we had to give it the top spot on our list.

9/10

It’s got a medium to strong hold, depending on the amount and length of hair that you’re starting with. We can’t say that we’re supremely blown away when working with hair that needs a high hold, but this product also wasn’t designed for that.

Don’t expect more than a day’s duration out of this. Indeed, we’d probably cap it at 14-16 hours. That’s, of course, usually more than enough for most men on most days.

Texture

9.2/10

It’s got a creamier texture than other clays, but it’s actually a pomade blend.

Application

9.0/10

Men are split on this front, and it may have to do with their expectations of straightforward clays or pomades. Overall, it’s fairly easy if you’re working with damp hair and you take the time to work it in your hands properly before placing on your hair. And, it’s definitely clump-free.

Washing ease

9.4/10

It’s rather easy to wash this product out; no complaints here.

Scent

9.0/10

The clean, natural smell comes from the essential oils in the mix and it goes away quickly. For as nice as it smells, we wouldn’t mind it lasting longer, but hey, we’re all about the natural with this product.

Key ingredients

9.6/10

Let’s just point out that this is marketed as a clay pomade before you start to lament the overwhelming lack of clay ingredients here.

It’s also more important to note that there are a lot of good things in this vegan product, the essential oils list is stunning (tea tree, sage, lavender, basil, just to start). And, it’s paraben, alcohol, added fragrance and colorant – free. Plus, these products aren’t tested on animals.

Overall Editor Score

9.2/10

If you’re after a vegan styling clay for men, this is the one you want. Besides the natural ingredients and its animal-friendly status, the smell of this clay is simply divine.

It also offers a medium to strong hold that should get you through the day without any hassles. Afterwards, you can wash it out super easily. Indeed, you may be able to get away without using a shampoo. (But, unless you’re a strict no-poo guy, we recommend using shampoo at least once a week to ensure there’s no residue left behind.)

Now, on to the big question, with pomade in the product name, should you expect some shine? No.

That said, you shouldn’t expect this to mattify greasy locks. It’s formulated like a pomade, with the finish of a clay. Whether you add it to damp or dry hair, you should expect a natural finish on your hair – that’s somewhere between matte and glisten. But, it definitely isn’t shiny. (If you’re looking for a natural/vegan product with some shine to it, we suggest other Jack Black products.)

All in, this is a clay we’d  ider even if the natural aspects weren’t important. If you’ve got hair that you describe as average all the way around (or just a little in one direction or another), give it a go.

8.7/10

Don’t opt for this product if you’re after a strong, all day hold. It’s not that type of clay. But if you want a light to medium hold that gets you through the day, this is brilliant.

It’s definitely not going to make it from sun-up to sun-down. You’ll get between 6-8 hours with it. But, you can reactivate it with water, so you’ll make it through the work day without hassle.

Texture

9.4/10

This product definitely has more of a clay  istency, but at the same time, it’s also a bit creamier than other clays. Somehow that makes it feel more luxurious than the price would suggest.

Application

9.2/10

You’ll need a dime-sized amount for most styles and lengths and it does tend to work best with mostly dry hair (though between dry and damp is often a matter of preference). You can use your fingers (and no hairdryer) to get a loose pomp, which is rather impressive.

Washing ease

9.4/10

It’s wonderfully easily to wash this out. Mostly it will come out with just water. But, it probably demands a shampoo every couple of days as it does ask for some soap to come off hands.

Scent

9.6/10

The manufacturer says it smells like tobacco – and this appears to be one case where they’re not lying. The scent is natural, hardly overpowering, and just about everyone loves it.

Key ingredients

9.0/10

Inside is a mix of microcrystalline and carnauba waxes as well as kaolin clay. In addition, there aren’t any parabens inside and these products aren’t tested on animals. (But, it’s not what you’d call a natural product.)

Overall Editor Score

9.2/10

Clays are almost ridiculously expensive. And, while there are other products that offer a matte finish, there aren’t any that add texture and volume as well as a decent hold. Clays really take the cake for that combination.

If you want to pay a little less for a clay than the average (which is about $8/ounce), you will need to compromise. You’ll need to do the same here, but nowhere near as much as with other “budget” options.

Sure, the hold is a little weaker than other clays, and the expected duration is definitely shorter, but most guys find the hold is more than enough, especially if their hair is on the thinner side. Guys with really thick hair will probably do better to look for a product expressly designed for a stronger hold.

One thing we really like about this clay is the smooth, workable texture of the product. It’s a little softer than you might expect and that means it’s easier to apply to dry and almost dry hair. It washes out even easier than that. And it smells incredible. Truly. You could ask for a lot less at this price, but with this clay, you don’t have to.

8.9/10

This product offers incredibly strong hold – on both dry and damp hair – and lasts all day and night. 

This product is thicker and denser than most on our list, which requires some effort to work in and out of your hair. Although it is great for both dry and damp hair, applying it to dry hair may be difficult to manage – so a towel-dried hair may be the way to go. You can either use your fingers or a comb to tame it in place.

Texture

8.7/10

This clay has a thick  istency, but without the gritty texture that most clays have – more like a wax. While that’s great for the hold, it is difficult to work out of the container. So we advise putting it under hot water while sealed to soften the product a bit before application.

Application

8.7/10

Before applying this clay, rub it thoroughly on your palms to soften the  istency. You can shape any hairstyle you like. If you want to restyle, simply run your fingers through it; no need to add water.

Washing Ease

9.5/10

This amazing hair clay is surprisingly easy to wash out despite the mix of its ingredients. Just water is okay, which is what you can’t always expect from a Layrite.

Scent

8.7/10

The aroma is not strong, it’s a subtle vanilla scent that smells good on hair.

Key Ingredients

8.8/10

Ingredients include a combination of castor oil, earth wax, beeswax, lanolin, and petrolatum. While not super common for ingredients cound in hair clay, they combine to create a waxy texture that is great for hair and provides an excellent all day hold.

Overall Editor Score

8.9/10

9/10

The hold is remarkably strong, given the somewhat unorthodox texture of this clay. It’s better than medium, but it’s far from the strongest.

Don’t expect miracles on duration. You’ll only achieve about 12 to 14 hours of control with this hair clay. That should get you through the day though, right?

Texture

8.8/10

The texture is a little unusual for a hair clay. It’s more like a liquid paste or a cream. Still, it’s quite thick in  istency. Strange, right? And totally worth the try.

Application

9.2/10

This goes on super easy – both on your hands and your hair. And, it doesn’t leave any greasy or waxy residue on your hands the way some products do. It’s easy to style in any direction you want, though if you’re looking for something with a lot of height, you’ll need to add in a wax or a hairspray. If you want a little more volume, use a hair dryer on the cool setting.

Washing ease

9.4/10

This is surprisingly easy to wash out. With plenty of beeswax, it’s almost amazing how easily it works out.

Scent

8.5/10

Some users find the scent to be way too strong. And, let’s be honest, it’s not the most masculine. Some think it smells a little like jasmine, others peg it closer to coconut or pineapple. Either way, it doesn’t have the earthy smell you would associate with a good clay.

Key Ingredients

8.8/10

Inside the confusing list of ingredients, you’ll find bentonite clay and beeswax (as you should expect). It’s also paraben free.

Overall Editor Score

9.0/10

Love the hold and natural appearance of a hair clay, but can’t stand the difficult to work with texture? You totally just found your game-changer product. Seriously. This doesn’t feel like a clay, but it sure works like a clay. It’s a little difficult to describe the texture until you try it, and we certainly advise that you do. With a satisfaction guarantee and good customer service, there’s little reason not to.

And it manages to tame waves and curls without any hassle. You’ve got to love that!

Of course, there’s a lot more to a hair product than the texture and you’re likely to be concerned with the hold and appearance more than the way it feels in your hands. Here, you’re bound to be pleasantly surprised. Despite being lightweight, you should expect a strong hold – unless you have very thick hair (in which case, you’ll need something with a much stronger hold). And yet, you’ll have a gorgeous matte finish that looks so enticingly natural.

Once you’ve got it in your hair, which is wonderfully easy to do, you won’t experience any of that nasty stickiness on your hands – and it’s wonderfully easy to wash out too. That’s a plus for any product, but especially for a clay.

But, you will need to trade something for the combination of easy in and easy out hair clay – and that’s the length of the hold. You shouldn’t expect it to last for weeks; it won’t. It probably won’t even give you 24 hours. But, it will give you a solid 12-14 hours of sheer bliss. And, despite the not-so-masculine aroma, there’s something about it that many guys seem to love.

All in, that makes it an almost perfect clay for guys that use it day in and day out. Give it a shot, you’re likely to find the same.

9.7/10

The hold on this is surprisingly strong and tends to last the entire day. Hair remains pliable enough to move and bend while still popping back into place. It’s little wonder we’ve given it the strong hold accolades,  right?

You can expect this to last the whole day. That’s really not bad for a clay.

Texture

8.6/10

The beeswax in this product provides a slightly sticky feeling. This is a rather thick and non-greasy clay.

Application

9.0/10

There are a few users that find this is a little too thick for what they’re looking for; they have a little difficulty with the application. However, most users rave about the ease of application (not to mention the desired result), which is made easier by the fact that you really only need a small amount (as little as a fingernail-sized blob). When applied to wet hair, you’ll maintain a little of the wet look. Application to dry and damp hair results in a smooth and natural appearance.

Washing ease

8.5/10

If there’s one point where this hair clay falls down, it’s with the ease of washing it out. The petroleum base mixed with beeswax makes it a little more difficult than we would like for a clay. Don’t skip the shampoo or you’ll get a few crunchy flakes after toweling off.

Scent

9.0/10

Like most styling products, the aroma of this hair clay is a little difficult to peg. It’s definitely earthy with hints of lemon, sage, and something like tobacco.

Key Ingredients

9.2/10

Inside, you’ll find bentonite clay and beeswax (no surprise there), and plenty of natural ingredients like lemon peel, fennel, and sage oils. It’s also paraben-free.

Overall Editor Score

9.0/10

Despite the relatively small number of hair clays on the market, the competition is fierce. And yet, this Baxter of California Clay Pomade easily made its way to the top of our list. Okay, it is a hybrid clay, but it performs so stunningly well that we had no choice but to give it serious honors.

As with most clays, this provides a natural, matte finish to your do. More than that, it adds serious texture and definition. No really, expect to add some volume if you apply this to damp hair and style with a hair dryer. At the same time, it’s absolutely perfect for a slicked back look. Your hair will feel and appear smooth and frizz-free, whatever your actual hair is like.

We’d like to add that there are many reports of users moving from brands like American Crew over to Baxter of California with great success. Their glowing reviews are echoed in the awards given by reputable sources such as Men’s Health and Details magazines. You’ll find similar raves from sources such as Ask Men and Huffington Post.

There are very few drawbacks which are almost negligible. For example, the price is high – but the product lasts a truly long time. The biggest setback is the trouble that some users have in washing it out. However, we still think it’s worth it.

8.8/10

At best, we’d describe this hold as medium. It’s really not a strong hold, and if your hair is on the longer side, you may find this offers a little less than average. That said, it holds up well through some difficult elements, including sweat, which is a real plus.

Many guys find that it lasts a good 14-18 hours. It doesn’t seem to ever last longer than that, but most men don’t expect more than 16 hours from a product. Just a quick word though, there are those that feel 12 hours is pushing it on this. So, you may need to take it with you if you’re planning an extended day out and about.

Texture

8.6/10

This is a little more gelatinous than most clays, which can be a little off-putting at first. But it’s also, somehow, quite natural feeling and breaks down easily in your hands, making it rather easy to apply.

Application

9.2/10

When applied to slightly damp hair, you should expect a light sheen to it, making it behave a little like a pomade in that regard. But, overall, most guys find this product goes in easily with no need to alter application methods.

Washing ease

9.5/10

This washes out almost too easily. Some guys find they don’t even need a shampoo to get this water-based product out of their hair. We still recommend it, of course, if you’re trying to avoid build-up, but you can expect this to be an easy wash.

Scent

8.5/10

People have a lot to say about the smell of this clay. It’s not for everyone. It mostly smells of clay with, perhaps, another earthy smell like tobacco mixed in. Some feel that it’s really off-putting while others quite like it. Either way, it dissipates quickly and if everything else is in place for you on this product, you shouldn’t let the smell stop you from trying it.

Key Ingredients

9.4/10

Inside, you’ll find petroleum mixed with bentonite clay. There’s also a fair amount of beeswax and lanolin waxes. We’re fans of the essential, carrot seed, and soybean oils.

Overall Editor Score

9.0/10

Overall, this clay is simply amazing, but it’s maybe not a bad idea to get the negatives out of the way first.

First, the smell is not something everyone can live with. It’s really earthy, but it can come across as a little chemically sometimes. Mostly, it’s just enough aroma to let you know that you’re working with a product, and it goes away quickly. But, if you’re super sensitive, you may want to move along.

Then there is the hold. If you’re after a super strong, super long hold, this is not the clay for you. It lasts reasonably long – and stands up to humidity and moisture (so you can feel secure at the gym), but it’s not a 24-hour hold. And, we can’t say it’s anything more than medium.

So what does this clay do really well?

It allows for a range of styles, usually on the messier side, though it’s also pretty good with short, tamed, combed styles. If you want a low pompadour without the glistening finish you get with gels or pomades, this is an excellent choice.

More importantly, it really does add some thickness to thin hair and allows guys with flat, straight hair to get a bit of texture without weighing down hair in either case. Almost surprisingly, it’s just as valuable to those with wavy hair.

The texture is a little strange for a clay, but given the smooth application and the ease of washing it out, we’re going to forgive it. Plus, the company selling it stands behind their products and seems to enjoy doing what they do; not everyone can make hair care that kind of fun.

9/10

If you dream of a hair with high definition, then you must give this product a try. Shape your hair to whatever style you want with this clay and it will maintain the same state all day.

Texture

8.8/10

It has a non-sticky and non-greasy lightweight texture that easily binds with hair to create any style you may want for the day, providing you the thickness you’ve always wanted.

Application

8.7/10

A small amount of clay is enough to get the job done. Use either your hands or a comb to work it through your locks, or even add a bit of water when styling for added pliability.

Washing Ease

8.7/10

This clay is as easy to wash out at the end of the day, but it may require using shampoo to completely get the clay out of your hair.

Scent

8.9/10

The minty smell is uplifting and refreshing. It has a rich and spicy aroma of spearmint and organic oils, like lavender, which leaves hair smelling fresh all day. Users find it mild and soothing.

Key Ingredients

9.0/10

Ingredients include a mix of certified natural essential oils of spearmint and vetiver, great for added thickness and moisture. In addition to the health benefits, these oils combine with citrus extracts and sweet wood for a lovely, subtle fragrance.

Overall Editor Score

8.9/10

As the title suggests, this Aveda Men Hair Clay is a good option if you want to add extra thickness to your hair. But not only that, this clay provides more precise texture and definition for a perfect finish.

Scanning through its ingredients, it’s composed of mostly all natural oils like spearmint, vetiver, and lavender that have antibacterial and calming properties that are good for the hair and scalp. Plus, they add to the soothing smell of the clay that most reviewers can’t get enough of.

This clay can maintain a great hold in for any style and will secure the shape in place while giving you the perfect amount of volume.

Though a bit pricey, a jar of this clay can last up to several months because you only need a dab of it to manage your hair. In that sense, it is not too bad for the price especially given that it does such a great job on hair.

8.7/10

When it comes to hold, this clay really shows up against the competition. It offers medium to strong-hold that stays pretty much in place all day, without appearing stiff or greasy.

Application

7.8/10

Since this clay has a sticky texture and dries out easily, one way to go is to wet your hands with water before applying it to your hair to make it more pliable. You can also dip the tightened container in hot water until it gets soft prior to the application. Then, you can style your hair in any way you want.

Texture

7.6/10

It is much more of a paste or clay; it is thick and tacky so it needs a little effort and practice to get the hand of styling.

Washing Ease

7.5/10

It’s a bit challenging to wash it off – doing a deep shampoo and two washes might be necessary if you want to avoid the sticky, flakey look. 

Scent

8.2/10

The smell is just fine; nothing specialy, but it fades away upon application so you won’t smell like you’re wearing anything at all.

Key Ingredients

8.9/10

The Mitch Matterial styling clay contains natural clay, strong fixatives, and thickening ingredients that help in keeping your hair in place and adds extra thickness, volume, and texture. It has no shine properties, which creates a more  sophisticated, modern look.

Overall Editor Score

8.1/10

To start with, everyone knows you can never go wrong with Paul Mitchell products. This Mitch Matterial hair clay is made specifically for men who love volume, texture, and thickness without the shiney, wet look; in that regard, it definitely slays.

With the thickening properties and strong fixatives this putty has to offer, you will have a perfect long-lasting hold that maintains the shape and style of your hair – giving you a modern look with a matte-finish. Even if you have straight or curly hair, styling is just as easy. Despite its thick  istency, this product provides excellent hold and finish.

While some users find the product easy to wash off with water, some recommend that you wash your hair twice with shampoo after using this clay or it will leave hair sticky and flakey. However, after several uses, your hair will adjust and this clay will wash off easily without hassle.

For the price ($6/ounce), it is overall a great deal. Aside from that, it will last you a long time – up to several months in fact! Which means lots of great hair days in your future.