After 26 hours of research evaluating 39 products, we picked Glossier Boy Brow as our top choice.
With almost four million Instagram posts under the hashtag #BrowsOnFleek (and counting!), it’s evident that great-looking eyebrows have become the breakout beauty feature of the last several years.
Whether you like it or not, everyone got pretty much swept into the craze. So finding the best brow gel makes sense.
Here’s the deal:
Thanks to makeup, there are plenty of ways for you to shape and shade your brows to get them looking full and pretty. So we are here to help you choose the best eyebrow gels on the market.
But whatever shading method you prefer — be it using the best eyebrow powder, a brow pencil, or a pomade – setting it with a reliable eyebrow gel is the secret to long-lasting and truly-striking arches.
Now:
Like all other makeup products, we know that choosing the best brow gel is a matter of personal preference.
This is why we picked seven of the best products to recommend to you, our dear reader.
The best eyebrow gels discussed below have been determined through hours and hours of research. Whatever eyebrow look you prefer, we’re sure you’ll find something phenomenal on the list below.
Enjoy!
#1 Best Eyebrow Gel Overall
Glossier Boy Brow
- Makes your eyebrows look naturally fuller
- Doesn’t stiffen or flake
- Features a conditioning formula
Pros
Glossier Boy Brow is designed to create naturally-pretty eyebrows. It’s a thickening eyebrow gel that makes brow hairs look fuller and healthier, making it ideal for creating both bushy and polished arches.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
9.8/10
Not into the made-up look but hate the look of sparse eyebrows? This might just be your perfect match.
Glossier’s Boy Brow does a beautiful job doing what brow gels are supposed to do: make us look like we were naturally born with luscious, pretty eyebrows. Achieving fluffy and bushy brows is as easy as applying this gel using upward strokes, while a more muted approach makes simple and polished brows possible, too.
The conditioning formula is a great bonus. It contains Oleic Acid, Lecithin, and Atelocollagen to nourish and moisturize your eyebrows. Over time, it’s supposed to enhance the look and thickness of your natural brow hairs.
Shade Range
9.3/10
You can buy the Boy Brow in either a clear variant or in one of three shades: Blond, Brown, and Black. Glossier’s branding is all about minimalism and flexibility, so we’re not that surprised about the lack of shade variety.
Although everyone can technically use the Clear Boy Brow, a few more shades in different undertones would have been nice.
Value
9.6/10
This eyebrow gel costs $16. It’s not something most of us would consider affordable. But considering it’s the best eyebrow gel overall, we’re more than happy to shell out a chunk of our beauty budget on it.
Overall Editor Score
9.6/10
#2 Best Natural Eyebrow Gel
Anastasia Beverly Hills Clear Brow Gel
- Great for achieving that naturally-fluffy look
- Provides all-day hold
- Works well with all types of brow products
Pros
Anastasia Beverly Hills’ brow gel is considered by many as their holy grail brow tamer – and for good reason. This product ensures that your brow hairs look exactly the way you want them to. It also boasts an all-day hold, as well as an easy to use applicator.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
9.8/10
If you’re the type who likes the look of brushed-up, feathery brows, this is the brow gel for you. This product is excellent for shaping the eyebrows and keeping them in place all day — perfect if you’re tired of dealing with brow hairs that have a mind of their own.
We also adore how natural this product looks on our eyebrows. In spite of its super sturdy hold, it doesn’t make brow strands look stiff, wet, or overly shiny.
Shade Range
9.5/10
The ABH Brow Gel has clear and tinted variants, with the available colors being Blonde, Auburn, Brunette, Caramel, Chocolate, Espresso, and Granite. We like the versatility of this lineup and the inclusion of different shades, although we must admit that the clear variant is our absolute favorite.
Value
9.4/10
At $22 apiece, we know this eyebrow gel may not be for everyone. But as we’ve said before: if you have some spare cash to fund your #browgoals, you can’t go wrong with this eyebrow gel.
Overall Editor Score
9.6/10
#3 Best Tinted Eyebrow Gel
NYX Tinted Brow Mascara
- Cheap
- Subtly yet effectively tints eyebrow hairs
- Easy-to-apply formula
Pros
This eyebrow gel effectively tints the eyebrows so they can match your hair color. It’s also great for reviving white or gray eyebrow hairs. It leaves a natural-looking finish and lasts all day, too.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
9.5/10
NYX’s formula leans toward the dry side, which is actually a plus since a wet formula can make tinting eyebrow hairs rather challenging. We love how lightweight and subtle its effect is, so if you want to make it seem like you were simply born with eyebrows that perfectly complement your hair color, we suggest you pick this up ASAP.
It doesn’t do much in the way of volumizing or “fluffing” eyebrow hairs, which can either be a good thing or a bad thing depending on the look you’re going for. It does hold your arches in place for most of the day, though — another pro that we really appreciate.
Shade Range
9.4/10
NYX Tinted Brow Mascara has five different shade options: Blonde, Brunette, Chocolate, Espresso, and Black. It’s a decent shade range that includes various depths and tones, so this brow gel should be able to accommodate most people.
Value
9.5/10
Although its MSRP lies around the $7 mark, this tinted brow mascara from NYX is frequently on sale on retailers like Amazon. That said, it’s a promising tinted brow gel that comes at an impressive price.
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
#4 Best Waterproof Eyebrow Gel
Maybelline TattooStudio Waterproof Eyebrow Gel
- Waterproof
- Stays on for up to two days
- Offers the best shade range
Pros
This smudge-proof and budge-proof eyebrow gel from Maybelline offers amazing value and performance for the price. It gives you fuller and defined-looking eyebrows by adhering to your skin and brow hairs for up to two days.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
9.4/10
This eyebrow gel has a sticky and tacky texture that new users might find intimidating to use. Once you get the hang of it, however, it should be all smooth-sailing (trust us!). You might also want to ditch the attached applicator for a thin angled brush if you have one at home.
This eyebrow gel does a decent job holding eyebrow hairs in place. Talking about the longevity of the tint on your skin is an entirely different matter, though, as it literally stays on for days! That said, this eyebrow gel is definitely for those who like to achieve fuller-looking eyebrows through the filled-in, pomade-like look. It doesn’t make your hair strands look thicker, so take note.
Shade Range
9.7/10
Available in 10 shades (Light Blonde, Blonde, Soft Brown, Medium Brown, Warm Brown, Chocolate Brown, Deep Brown, Auburn, Black Brown, Black), you’ll probably find something that will match you perfectly (or near perfectly, at least) if you decide to try this product. Definite win!
Value
9.4/10
The Maybelline TattooStudio Waterproof Eyebrow Gel has an MSRP of $12.99, but you’ll probably be able to buy it for cheaper from Amazon. Its awesome staying power and value-for-money make it the best waterproof eyebrow gel in our books.
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
#5 Best Long-Lasting Eyebrow Gel
MILK Makeup KUSH Fiber Brow Gel
- Impressive shade selection
- Thickens your eyebrow hairs
- Transfer-proof
Pros
MILK Makeup’s KUSH Fiber Brow Gel is all about conditioning and thickening your brow hairs while providing great hold. It contains tinted fibers that give you fuller-looking arches. It also has a dense and firm brush for easy and even application.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
9.5/10
This tinted eyebrow gel has one of the most interesting formulas we’ve encountered. It’s packed with heart-shaped fibers that give it a somewhat thick and dry (but still easy to manage) texture.
The real star of the show, however, is the hemp-derived cannabis seed oil that conditions, nourishes, and sets your eyebrows without the dreaded stiff and crunchy feeling. We love that it holds our eyebrow hairs in place for the entire day, too. Overall, if you’re looking for a fiber-infused brow gel that offers great hold, this eyebrow gel is your best bet.
Shade range
9.5/10
This eyebrow gel is available in 8 shades: Haze (for warm blondes), MJ (for cool blondes), Dub (for auburn hair), Herb (for neutral medium brown hair), Dutch (a medium-dark brown color), Grind (deep brown), Diesel (for warm very dark brown or black hair), and Cypher (for cool very dark brown or black hair).
Clearly, MILK Makeup did a good job of being as inclusive as possible – something that we can all appreciate.
Value
9.2/10
The KUSH Fiber Brow will set you back $20 – quite pricey for a brow setter, but nonetheless worth the investment.
Overall Editor Score
9.4/10
#6 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Gel
Rimmel Brow This Way Lightweight Eyebrow Gel
- Lightweight
- Affordable
- Has an easy-to-maneuver brush
Pros
Rimmel’s Brow This Way Eyebrow Gel is the ideal brow gel for gentle shaping and taming. It comes in both tinted and clear variants. Plus, it’s beginner-friendly and comes at a great price.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
8.9/10
This eyebrow gel is a great pick if your eyebrows require some gentle direction. It has a wet formula that takes a couple of minutes to dry down. But once it has set, it feels lightweight and comfortable — almost like you have nothing on your eyebrows.
It performs best when used on bare brows, so it’s a great tool for no-makeup days when all you’re looking for is a bit of polishing and definition. It does a great job of shaping eyebrow hairs and giving your arches a cleaner look, but note that it isn’t the best for taming super thick and unruly hair strands.
Shade Range
9.2/10
This eyebrow gel comes in both clear and tinted versions, with the available shades being dark brown, medium brown, and blonde. We think this is a pretty decent shade range, plus the clear variant is always a safe choice if none of the tinted options seem right for your hair color.
Value
9.3/10
You can score a tube of this eyebrow gel for around $4, which makes it a great pocket-friendly choice.
Overall Editor Score
9.1/10
#7 Best Budget Eyebrow Gel
Covergirl Easy Breezy Volumizing Brow Gel
- Makes the eyebrows look fuller
- Waterproof
- Natural-looking
Pros
This eyebrow gel is a great budget option if you want fuller yet natural-looking brows. It won’t leave your eyebrow hairs looking wet or stiff. It’s also transfer- and waterproof, which means it will last all day.
Product Ratings
Texture and Hold
9/10
If you’re looking for something that will help you shape and control stray hairs, this brow gel is definitely worth a look. It will hold your eyebrows in place with its fade-proof and waterproof formula. We love that it doesn’t leave a wet look, although note that you’ll definitely feel it “sitting” on your eyebrows for at least the first couple of hours.
If there’s one thing we don’t love 100% about this product, it’s probably the density of the applicator. It doesn’t have a lot of bristles, but it somehow ends up picking up a lot of product. Wiping the excess gel off the brush easily solves this issue, though.
Shade Range
9.2/10
Covergirl’s Easy Breezy Brow Gel comes in four variants: clear, light, medium, and deep. If you can get away with neutral-toned eyebrows, you’ll probably be able to use one of the tinted versions. Otherwise, we suggest you go with the clear variant.
Value
9.1/10
This drugstore brow gel costs anywhere between $5 to $10 depending on where you buy it. So if you’re looking for a drugstore brow setter that offers impressive hold, know that this Covergirl product is the best budget eyebrow gel we can recommend.
Overall Editor Score
9.1/10
