It doesn’t matter whether you use an electric razor or you prefer a more traditional wet shave, your skin is bound to suffer some irritation every morning. That’s precisely why post-shave treatments were developed. And, they’ve really blown up over the past few years.
Some men may prefer a small variety of men’s aftershave treatments. But, if you’re looking for the perfect all-arounder, make sure you check out the Lovablepicks team’s number one best aftershave. It could just transform your skin – and skincare routine – forever.
Of course, we didn’t just consider ingredients in the forty-odd hours of research dedicated to this best men’s aftershave list. We also considered price, aroma, moisturizing ability – and of course, whether real men have found each product to work as promised.
And, we’ve clearly found the best of the best men’s aftershaves in the process. But don’t just take our word for it. Keep reading to see for yourself.
Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
#1 Best Overall Men’s Aftershave Product
The Art of Shaving Unscented After-Shave Balm
- There’s no overpowering fragrance
- Super soothing for all skins
- Calms burning and irritation
Pros
The grape seed extract in this aftershave balm revitalizes skin while the essential oils condition it. Guys also love the soothing effects of shea butter and glycerin.
Product Ratings
Features
9.5/10
We love that this an alcohol-free formula. It’s also free from synthetic dyes. What it does have is all that lovely grapeseed extract, shea butter, and vitamin C from citrus extracts. You’ll also find glycerin and jojoba for an aftershave that goes on smoothly and is completely absorbed by your skin.
Fragrance
9.5/10
This particular balm from The Art of Shaving is fragrance-free so, you never need to worry about offending anyone – at least by the aroma of your aftershave. However, there are scented varieties from the same line you can try if you prefer another scent. In case you’re wondering, the folks at Men’s Health prefer the lavender variety – especially for nighttime shavers.
Value
9.5/10
It’s not cheap, we’ll say that much. The price per ounce is generally about $7.20. But, it’s a winning product and doesn’t contain alcohol, so…
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
If you’ve got sensitive skin, this may be just the aftershave product for you. It’s filled with grapeseed extract, shea butter, and vitamin C – all of which work to improve the health of delicate skins.
This incredible product ranks high on our list of men’s aftershave products because of it’s healing and refreshing powers when applied to sensitive skins. Although this is certainly not the cheapest product in the world of aftershave treatments, it is certainly worth every penny. And you’ll know that as soon as you apply it to your face the first time.
What’s the Bottom Line? It’s difficult to find an aftershave that’s so highly recommended and doesn’t contain any alcohol. It’s perfect for oily skins as well as super-sensitive faces. It’s our fave for the awesome composition, the way it soothes skin, and the fact that it doesn’t stink. We wouldn’t mind if it were cheaper, though.
#2 Best Aftershave for Irrititable Skin
Nivea for Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm with Active Comfort System
- Subtle, manly scent that garners impressive reviews
- Calms and soothes skin quickly
- The refreshing, cooling sensation is great for sensitive skin
Pros
Not only does this aftershave soothe skin after a shave, it prevents shaving irritation from future shaves through its skin-improving formula.
Product Ratings
Features
9.5/10
This doesn’t have a lot of fancy ingredients, but it also doesn’t have any alcohol. The key ingredients are chamomile and heads of vitamin extracts. We are going to point out that this aftershave balm does have parabens, but as of now, the FDA and World Health Organization haven’t made the link between cancer and parabens.
Fragrance
9.5/10
Sandalwood. It can come on a little strong, but many men (and lots of women) find it’s incredibly manly.
Value
9.5/10
At just over $2 per fluid ounce, this is one of the most cost-effective aftershave products. And, it’s one of the reasons it features so high on our list.
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
This post-shave balm is great for men with sensitive skin. And, it’s Amazon’s number one best seller, so you’d better believe that this balm is special.
It’s made in Germany and doesn’t contain any alcohol, so it won’t dry our your skin. On top of that, it’s brimming with vitamin E and chamomile, so you can expect a smooth, moisturized complexion. Daily users cite skin improvement over time. The only potential drawback to this product is it’s stronger scent. Many men like it, but it doesn’t have a universal appeal.
What’s the Bottom Line? This is perfect for daily use, especially since it helps to relieve bumps and shaving lumps. We should note that shaving is an abrasive exercise so all freshly shaved skin is irritated, but this one is perfect for guys that experience that to the max.
#3 Best Aftershave Lotion
Proraso After Shave Lotion
- Smells exactly the way you want an aftershave to smell
- Cooling and refreshing (there is a slight difference)
- Great finish to an awesome shave
Pros
This aftershave lotion prevents bumps and rashes as well as ingrown hairs. Proraso really offers a smooth, invigorating finish to your shaving experience.
Product Ratings
Features
9.5/10
If you’re excited about natural extracts, you’ll want to try this aftershave lotion right away. Inside, you’ll find refreshing menthol, purifying eucalyptus, and witch hazel. That last ingredient naturally heals razor rash, which we know all men want – even those who don’t experience it badly. What won’t you find in this bottle? Parabens, sulfates, or phthalates; see, told you it was an excellent product.
Fragrance
9.5/10
The menthol is immediately evident in the aroma of this aftershave lotion. You’ll also smell the eucalyptus and perhaps a bit of mint. Overall, it smells incredibly clean and compelling.
Value
9.5/10
Nope. While it’s not the cheapest product on the list, it retails for just over $4 per fluid ounce. That’s really not bad, especially given the ingredients and reputation behind this lotion.
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
#4 Best Aftershave for Dry Skin
Baxter of California After Shave Balm
- You’ll fall in love with the aroma of this aftershave
- Cooling and revitalizing
- Soothes irritation and prevents razor bumps
Pros
The allantoin in this aftershave formula treats the stinging burns left by razors – and other skin irritations. Meanwhile, aloe vera reduces inflammation. All in all, a brilliant combination.
Product Ratings
Features
9.5/10
You won’t find any alcohol here, but you will find parabens. However, there are plenty of natural extracts that do the work you want them to. The menthol cools skin while tea tree oil is an antibacterial and natural moisturizer. It’s a solid formula, though you may need to look elsewhere if you’re concerned about parabens. The consistency is on the thin side, but you don’t need a lot and it does absorb quickly.
Fragrance
9.5/10
There’s a sensational lemony, masculine scent to this aftershave balm. We know that’s difficult to imagine, but it’s good!
Value
9.0/10
Probably not. It’s a little less than $5 per fluid ounce, so it’s middle of the road as far as aftershave products go.
Overall Editor Score
9.3/10
This brilliant aftershave is rich with ingredients that relieve sensitivity after shaving. It’s both cooling and hydrating, without any alcohol in the mix. It’s absolutely one of the best choices for guys with dry skin. It also works wonders on irritated faces.
Think of this aftershave balm from Baxter of California as a moisturizer that forms part of your daily shaving routine. That’s what it reminds us of – a super hydrating formula rather than cooling. But, it does a fair job of that too.
What’s the Bottom Line? We love, love, love this product for men with dry skin. Whether you live in a dry climate or you’ve had one too many late nights (not drinking water), this is an awesome fix. It’s not expensive, but you should look elsewhere if you have naturally oily skin – or if you have a problem with parabens.
#5 Best Budget Aftershave Lotion
Clubman Pinaud After Shave Lotion
- Out-of-this-world, enticing scent
- Terrific sensation that lasts all day
- Super refreshing
Pros
The fragrance of this aftershave is undeniably suave and masculine. And, the soothing formula helps contain and heal razor nicks.
Product Ratings
Features
9/10
There’s not a lot in this formula. Well, not much besides water and alcohol. There’s a bit of fragrance and some moss extracts. The point behind this aftershave product is to instantly cool razor-irritated skin. However, you’ll still need a moisturizer after soothing your face with this product.
Fragrance
9.0/10
If you want to know what an old-school barbershop smells like, open this bottle. If you already know that aroma, you know how this aftershave smells.
Value
9.5/10
Not at all. This aftershave works out to less than $1.30 per fluid ounce.
Overall Editor Score
9.2/10
This aftershave is a classic product – which is code for cost-effectiveness because it includes an alcohol base. Still, if your skin can handle it, you’ll find this is one of the most skin refreshing products on the market.
Not only is this aftershave reasonably priced, but it’s also great for soothing inflamed skin. This product is also an antiseptic, so it should be on your shelf for those nicks and burns you have to deal with on occasion. It may be a little much for daily use, though, especially if you’re averse to stronger aromas.
What Type of Aftershave Is This? Lotion, though it’s more of a splash.
What’s the Bottom Line? You may not want to use this aftershave every day – no matter how inexpensive it may be. That said, there are benefits to keeping a bottle of this on hand. It’s the swiftest way to stop the burning and sanitize any cuts you received while shaving. Open this aftershave for those moments, and then chase it with a moisturizer.
#6 Best Aftershave for Sensitive Skins
Geo F Trumper Sandalwood Skin Food
- The fragrance wows most men (and women) instantly
- Doesn’t irritate sensitive skin
- Smooth application
Pros
Nourishes skin as it seals smoothness underneath. This product is light and non-oily as it’s a glycerine-based formula.
Product Ratings
Features
9.5/10
There are some pluses and some minuses when you consider the ingredient list of this aftershave lotion. It does have alcohol and added fragrances, but it doesn’t have any parabens. And you’ll find glycerine and flower oil on the list. The consistency of the formula is somewhat perfect, though; it’s neither too thin or thick, too watery or too oily. Guys love it.
Fragrance
9.5/10
There’s a sandalwood scent to this (as the bottle will tell you).
Value
9.5/10
It’s over $5 per fluid ounce. That’s on the higher side for an aftershave, but it is paraben-free and you can expect to pay a bit more for that privilege until the FDA establishes a concrete link between parabens and cancer (or any other serious condition).
Overall Editor Score
9.5/10
This product ranks among the very best when it comes to aftershave treatments. That’s because it’s hardly just an aftershave lotion – it offers a whole lot more.
For a start, this can be used before shaving to protect your skin. Or, it can be used as an aftershave treatment to hydrate irritated skin. Not only that, but this skin product is slightly thicker than a lotion, more like a balm. And that can make a big difference for those with dry skin. If you’re not sold on the product yet, consider that it’s also available in a variety of fragrances (created from moisturizing essential oils) – so you can choose which aftershave lotion works best for you.
What Type of Aftershave Is This? Lotion
What’s the Bottom Line? Guys love this for the incredible scent and because it does exactly what it promises to do. It’s supremely moisturizing despite the presence of alcohol, and it is paraben-free. If it were cheaper, we would probably love it more.
#7 Best Aftershave for Active Men
Neutrogena Men Razor Defense Post Shave Lotion
- Very soothing and moisturizing
- Refreshing scent that won’t overpower even sensitive noses
- Absorbs quickly without an oily residue
Pros
Quickly reduces inflammation and irritation on freshly-shaved skin. Heals dry skin and even soothes sun-damaged faces.
Product Ratings
Features
9.2/10
Yikes, the ingredient list for this Neutrogena aftershave lotion is a little confusing. There aren’t any oils or dyes, but there are parabens and alcohol. It’s still glycerine-based and there are plenty of natural extracts including soybean, witch hazel, and aloe. Really, it’s a unique mix but perhaps that’s why it works so well.
Fragrance
9.2/10
There’s a light, refreshing smell to this lotion. There isn’t a seriously identifiable scent, but it is clean and manly.
Value
9.2/10
It’s closer to the expensive side than we’re totally comfortable with at roughly $6 per fluid ounce, so you must be sure it’s something you truly want to invest in.
Overall Editor Score
9.2/10
This is one of the few aftershave treatments available on the market that has no oils and no dyes. It’s best for guys with naturally dry skin that need a bit of regulated moisture.
This reasonably priced post-shave lotion works to heal the painful red bumps that can appear on dry skin during your shaving routine. It’s also been shown to improve the manageability of your facial hair, and it is widely recommended by men that suffer from the driest of skins. Plus it’s light and it never feels too heavy on your skin.
What Type of Aftershave Is This? Lotion
What’s the Bottom Line? There are some downsides to this lotion, including the use of parabens and the cost. But there are upsides too. We enjoy the pleasant fragrance and natural extracts. More than that, we’re happy that it provides relief from all sorts of burns and pains, including sunburns. Because it’s lightweight, it never feels like it’s clogging your skin. We like it a lot, but have to put it at the bottom of the list due to the price and ingredients.
